When you’ve handled enough T206s, certain patterns start to take shape. It starts by noticing something small that seems a little odd on a certain card. Most of the time these slight variations between cards are due to the inexact nature of the printing processes and don’t point us toward a larger pattern. However, after you see the same oddities a few times with the same card, or a group of cards that can be linked together in some way, that’s when some interesting patterns can start to take shape.
Typically the articles that I write are completely researched before I publish them, but this group of articles will be a little different. With this subject matter, it’s hard to “prove” anything, so I am content to just throw the idea out there for now. One huge obstacle in trying to put together the pieces of this puzzle is that these 150-350 Series Old Mills are scarce. Connecting the dots necessarily requires putting faith in the conclusions drawn from examining a small set of examples. But, I figure I have handled more 150-350 Old Mills than just about anyone, so I feel qualified to throw out a new theory regarding them. I’ll be interested to see what other people think, and I will continue to delve into the topic in the future.
This series of articles is going to take a look at the three backs noted above, but it feels natural to start with Old Mill, even though they were printed last. I’ve studied T206s with Old Mill backs more extensively than any other back, and it was looking at Old Mills that lead me down this train of thought.
There are three distinct print qualities that I have observed on dozens of cards from the 150-350 Series Old Mill Subset:
1. Clean, crisp images that look more like 150 Series images than 350 Series
2. “Dark Ink” cards that are much darker and more heavily inked than other cards
3. “Washed Out” images that lack the clarity of #1 and tend to be a bit lighter as well
These three distinct “looks” of Old Mills from the 150-350 Series lead me to one obvious conclusion, and one that may not be so obvious. First, because these Old Mills can be classified into three distinct groupings, clearly that means each group was printed separately. What it doesn’t tell us is whether there is any pattern to be found. It’s very possible that different runs on the press were just inked to varying degrees, which created the different results that we can see above.
I think there were three or more different print runs for 150-350 Series Old Mills. I also think the different print runs were made up of a different set of players/poses on the sheets. There seem to be some players that were not printed on the “washed out” sheets, and likewise with the “dark ink” sheets. In Part Two, I’ll delve into the “dark ink” 150-350 Series Old Mills and we’ll see what patterns and theories we can infer from them.